Herd
Get App
The Case podcast cover art

Best The Case Episodes

ByBarstool Sports
20 episodes

On February 4th, 2021, 23-year-old Sandra Birchmore was found dead in her apartment by the Canton Police. The Medical Examiner ruled it a suicide but friends and family have their doubts. 19 months later, three Stoughton Police officers have resigned including one who is the last known person to see Sandra alive.You can find every episode of this show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or YouTube. Prime Members can listen ad-free on Amazon Music. For more, visit barstool.link/thecasepodcast

#1

Jennifer

The inaugural episode dives deep into the mysterious disappearance of 16-year-old Jennifer Fay, setting the tone for the series. Kirk Minihane speaks with Jennifer's friends and explores the chilling aftermath of her vanishing, making it a compelling start for new listeners.

2021-04-05•44m
#2

Interrogation

This episode features a gripping 2.5-hour interrogation of Kevin Maler, a person of interest in Jennifer Fay's case. The intensity and depth of the conversation unveil new layers of mystery and suspicion, making it a must-listen for true crime enthusiasts.

2021-05-03•1h 25m
#3

Dottie & Yvette

In this penultimate episode, Kirk Minihane revisits the three-decade-long search for answers regarding Jennifer Fay's disappearance. The emotional weight and unresolved questions will resonate deeply with listeners, drawing them into the heart of the investigation.

2021-05-17•44m

Listen to your favourite podcasts.

Now ad-free.

Download herd and enjoy uninterrupted, high-quality podcasts without the wait.

Download on the
App Store
#4

Hiding

The season finale unveils critical information from the Oconee County Sheriff's Office that may unravel a web of deceit surrounding Jennifer's case. This episode serves as a captivating conclusion to Season One, leaving listeners eager for more.

2021-05-24•44m
#5

Update: Kevin Maler Charged with Murder and Kidnapping in the Death of Kevin Craig

This episode provides shocking updates as Kevin Maler faces murder and kidnapping charges, reigniting interest in the ongoing case. The discussion surrounding these developments offers new insights and keeps the narrative fresh and engaging.

2022-09-08•56m
#6

12 Hours

In the first episode of Season 2, the circumstances surrounding Sandra Birchmore's tragic death are examined in detail. This episode's in-depth exploration of the case will captivate new listeners and draw them into the unfolding mystery.

2022-11-29•23m
#7

Oh, the Places You'll Go

This episode sheds light on the controversial relationships of Stoughton Police Officer Robert Devine, revealing disturbing patterns that link to Sandra Birchmore's case. The mix of personal stories and systemic issues makes it a compelling listen.

2022-12-06•19m
#8

Surveillance Reaction + Mailbag

In this episode, the team explores surveillance footage related to Sandra Birchmore's last moments, providing chilling insights and prompting listener questions. The blend of investigative findings and audience engagement makes it a standout episode.

2022-12-20•1h 4m
#9

Joshua Heal

This episode investigates Joshua Heal's connections to Sandra Birchmore, revealing vital information that was previously kept under wraps. The exploration of his role adds a new layer of intrigue to the ongoing story, making it essential for new listeners.

2023-01-10•34m
#10

The Widower

In this captivating episode, Kirk Minihane interviews women connected to Kevin Maler, a person of interest in several cases. The contrasting narratives provide a deeper understanding of Maler, making it a compelling listen for those interested in the psychological aspects of true crime.

2021-05-10•37m